Friday, April 13, 2007

chapter 25, 26 & Online reading

- Chapter 25 -

Ok this chapter has been very interesting. Dawn talks about hymnals vs. projectors screens. At the beginning of the chapter she states that “I don’t intend to talk about preferences…” but that is to the point that she takes it in the end of the chapter.
She talks about people trying to mimic larger churches, but that is not always the case. Some times people realize that there is need for this change, but she does not say anything about that at all.
Next she gives the pros and the cons of hymnals and projectors. This is where it starts to get a little bias. She gives 10 advantages for projectors compared to the disadvantages numbering at 13. But they are good points, I’ll give her that, but the problem comes when she starts talking about hymnals. The number of advantages almost doubles the disadvantages in this set. Except this is the opposite of the previous set, by showing more advantages than the disadvantages. You be the judges as to the meaning of this. But the disadvantages to using hymnals are major, not minor, disadvantages. [If you would like to know the disadvantages please ask and I’ll give you them.]
At the end of the chapter she said something that made me mad. She said, “ to see words only on a screen narrows the possibilities available to the worshiper for reflection.”
If a person is a true worshiper they would not have to worry about this one bit. People can memorize the song then reflect on it, and the statement really goes both ways.

- Chapter 26 -

I was told a fictional story on Wednesday that I think is appropriate for this blog. It was about a guy who said he could answer any question biblically. But what happened was he was missing the whole translation of what is truly meant. And I think that is what Dawn is doing on page 299. I don’t know maybe I’m misunderstanding her, but I don’t think that I am. She says that she is biblically faithful, but I need to point out that if she thinks that hymns is “where it’s at” that is not biblical. Paul mentions hymns, psalms, and spiritual songs. Now the term spiritual songs can be taken different ways. I take it as to mean songs of the day or a song that only God can give. And to say that God isn’t in “songs of the day” is limiting God on what he can do [and that is my opinion].


- 7 things Ben learned from Bono (U2) -

All of these are very good ways of getting people involved and how a worship leader could be. Thanks for sharing this. It’s pretty cool

1 comment:

Brent Salsbury said...

Totally agree with everything you said. I especially like your comment on Chapter 26. It's so true!!